What makes a magazine ad make you sit back, smile, and think that is clever? In the examples examined in this 2021 article, The Economist’s wit does more than decorate a subscription pitch: it invites readers to recognize themselves as the sort of person who would get the joke.
I could Kissinger you
If you want to understand The Economist brand, start by clicking here. Described by one industry insider as the best advert of the last fifty years, it’s typical of the magazine as a whole: pithy, blunt, and perhaps a little haughty.
The most striking aspect of this iconic ad, however, isn’t that it was published—but that it’s been matched. Have a look at this, which cheekily claims that “99% of 1%ers are subscribers.” Or this, which calls The Economist a place “where guesses become educated.” Or this (my personal favorite), which implies the only way to talk cogently to (controversial) geopolitical titan Henry Kissinger is to read The Economist.
All these ads, all that wit, get to the core of what The Economist is—a sophisticated publication for sophisticated people. That last note is especially important. After all, the point of all these ads is ultimately to make the reader feel clever by recognizing themselves in the ad and choosing the magazine.
The clever move is to let the audience experience the identity on offer. A reader who catches the reference has already taken part in the ad. The ad lets the reader try on a small part of what subscribing promises.
Taking a stand
The wit also has an editorial stance behind it. In the examples discussed here, the magazine attaches a bright Economist-red banner to its mast. Readers are invited to recognize a point of view as well as a clever line.
The publication’s founding mission dates to 1843: “a severe contest between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our progress.”
That hints at The Economist’s editorial stance. This is an old-fashioned liberal publication. To that end, The Economist consistently makes clear that it wants the government to keep out—of wallets and bedrooms alike.
Why does that matter to the advertising? The mission and the wit offer a related identity: a reader who wants to understand the world and regards independent thought as part of who they are. The positioning has something more definite to say than “we have interesting articles.”
A mission does not have to win everyone over to clarify a publication’s appeal. Here it gives the cleverness a direction. The ad invites a reader into an outlook; the publication then has to give that reader something worth returning for.
The extensions address other jobs for the same kind of reader.
The 2021 version of this case also pointed to podcasts, MBA guidance, GMAT preparation and economic forecasting alongside the magazine—or “newspaper,” as it calls itself. Together, those offerings carried the publication’s interest in informed judgment into several parts of a reader’s life.
The connection is the reader’s interest in understanding and acting on the world: following an issue, assessing a business education, preparing for an exam, or examining an economic outlook. The extensions are intelligible because they serve related purposes, even though they are different products.
That is a sharper test than simply broadening a brand. Does the additional offering serve a recognizable need of the audience the brand has chosen? The language should explain that relationship rather than rely on a familiar logo to do the work.
The wit and the wider offer share a condition: the reader must recognize the invitation. “Where guesses become educated” gives that invitation a wonderfully economical form. It leaves the reader to supply the rest.
Want copy that could make even Secretaries of State sit up and take notice? The cleverclogs at MarketSmiths have got you covered—whatever your politics.
Related client work
MarketSmiths Case Study
One of the most famous universities on earth, Stanford University was gearing up to start groundbreaking work on campus. But without a robust environmental health and safety website, progress was slow. Unfortunately, it’s existing copy was clunky, confusing, and hard to navigate. Not for long. After tapping MarketSmiths, we worked closely with both the university and a hired communications agency to put it right, revising hundreds of pages, from Working Safely with Rabbits to the Laser Safety Manual. After relaunching the website, Stanford was ready to start its expansion—and had a website to match its prestige.