Originally published June 1, 2022; updated October 29, 2026.
Buying a used car involves several questions that sound alike until your money is at stake. Is the asking price competitive? Is the vehicle in good condition? Can you rely on the seller? A reassuring answer to one does not settle the others.
George Akerlof’s “The Market for Lemons” used uncertainty about product quality to explain a market problem: when buyers cannot reliably distinguish good goods from bad, their willingness to pay may drive higher-quality offerings out. The example does not mean every dealer knows every defect or every buyer has no information. It asks what happens when the two sides cannot evaluate the same thing on equal terms.
That makes CarGurus an interesting communication case. The marketplace puts comparisons and other people’s experiences closer to the buying decision. Its value lies in making particular questions easier to investigate—not making uncertainty disappear.
Make the comparison easier to inspect.
A marketplace can collect information that a buyer would otherwise have to gather across several dealerships. Vehicle details, listing histories, prices, and customer reviews offer different perspectives. Putting them together makes the search more useful; it does not make every record complete or every review impartial.
CarGurus’ communication centers on trust and transparency. The important question is how the interface gives those words substance. A reader can compare a listing, investigate a dealer, and follow up on a discrepancy instead of relying solely on the seller’s description.
Give other customers a role without making their verdict universal.
Dealer reviews add something a price model cannot: an account of someone’s interaction with the business. Did the dealer answer questions? Did the advertised vehicle turn out to be available? What happened when the customer visited?
Those observations can help a buyer decide what to ask next. But a positive dealer review does not inspect the particular car on the screen. Nor does one unhappy reviewer settle the quality of every transaction. The copy should help readers use each signal for the question it can answer.
Explain what the rating measures.
CarGurus calls its estimate Instant Market Value (IMV). Its explanation of the service describes Deal Ratings as price-comparison signals based on comparable listings and relevant vehicle and market information. Dealer reviews supply a separate kind of evidence.
A favorable price rating is not a certification of condition, reliability, safety, title, or service quality. Vehicle-history checks, an appropriate independent inspection, and confirmation of the transaction terms answer questions the price signal does not.
That distinction makes the communication stronger, not weaker. “Here is how this price compares” gives a buyer something specific to use. “You can now trust the whole purchase” asks one measure to do several jobs it cannot perform.
Make the commercial relationship visible.
CarGurus describes revenue from participating dealers and partners through subscriptions, advertising, enhanced placement, and certain transaction services. It also says a dealer’s commercial relationship does not change the Deal Rating. Paid visibility and the rating itself are different things.
The useful marketing principle is not that a marketplace must choose between serving buyers and earning revenue. It is that people should understand what a signal means, how the service earns money, and where the next decision belongs. Clear boundaries help the buyer use the information with confidence.
Information that complicates a sale can still help the buyer.
When describing Amazon’s choice to include both good and bad reviews for products Jeff Bezos stated:
“…We make money when we help customers make purchase decisions. Negative reviews are helpful in making purchase decisions. So it’s a very customer-centric point of view. Negative reviews will be helpful for customers, and that will ultimately sell more products than if you tried to cherry-pick the reviews.”
The argument in that quotation is useful even without treating it as a complete explanation of either company’s growth. Information that complicates a sale can still help a customer make a better decision.
CarGurus makes several parts of the investigation easier to conduct in one place. Buyers still complete the purchase with the dealer and need to resolve the questions relevant to that vehicle and those terms. A helpful marketplace explains the path rather than claiming to replace it.
For a brand selling confidence, that is a consequential writing task: turn an abstract assurance into information people can actually inspect, compare, and act on.
Related client work
Regal Credit Management expanded its business
Having developed a thriving credit management business stateside, Regal Credit Management wanted to expand to the United Kingdom. However, with scarce experience across the Atlantic, it was hard to get the right tone for British customers, especially ones unfamiliar with credit management. But after tapping MarketSmiths (especially the resident Brits!) Regal—known as PM Credit Management in the U.K.—soon found the right path. With tight deadlines, we revamped everything from Regal’s website to promotional flyers to product names—all to make them sing for new British audiences. Our hard work soon paid off. Regal quickly saw increased client interest, and used our copy to boost its credentials with partners in London. In short, we’ve helped secure Regal a foothold in the old world—and get the British public on the road to stronger credit.
Need sweet and refreshing copy that makes a buying decision clearer? The MarketSmiths team can help!