The Generative Search Shock: Competing When AI Owns the Above-the-Fold

Today, getting clicks isn’t about rankings; it’s about gaining the trust of our AI overlords—or in other words, creating content that positions you as an authoritative source worthy of being summarized by Gen AI.

Generative search is changing the game in these key ways.

Everything in life is a competition—the only thing that changes is the rulebook. 

When it comes to competing for consumers’ attention online, Generative AI just changed the name of the game. While SEO keywords for high rankings used to be the way to get ahead, the introduction of AI overviews makes rankings largely irrelevant. 

When AI overviews are present in search results, organic CTRs fall sharply. And with Google expanding AI overviews globally, it’s time for brands to learn the new rules.

1. Context is king

Do keywords still matter? The short answer is yes. But playing in a field dominated by AI means using keywords in a different way. Identify searches that commonly trigger AI overviews, then use segmented keywords—groups of related words around a certain topic—and semantically related terms that address those searches. 

Semantically related words, or words that are conceptually linked, include things like “pizza” and “dough,” or “content marketing” and “writer.” Semantically related words aren’t necessarily secondary keywords, although they can be. Instead, they’re terms or phrases that lend context to your keywords. This context is crucial, because it helps GenAI process your content

2. Scannability pays

Writing for AI means using concise statements that directly address search queries, offering real value rather than empty word salads. Structure your content into scannable sections with clear headers, short paragraphs, bullet points, and lists. Help AI quickly process your content by including a quick overview at the top, and consider adding an FAQ section for common search queries related to your topic.

3. Authority is your entrypoint

Gen AI tries to use content that it deems trustworthy. Cite relevant, high-authority sources and weave in data and statistics if relevant to your topic. But don’t rely too much on secondary content. Original insights and proprietary data count for more than regurgitated facts.

Strengthening your brand through cross-channel patterns also boosts authority, increasing visibility. Expand into channels like LinkedIn, SubStack, and YouTube, backlinking to your written content and vice versa.

4. Schema markup matters

Schema markup, or structured data markup, is code that helps search engines better understand your content. Schema markup is what Google uses to pull details like ratings and prices into search results. In the age of AI, schema markup can help AI engines quickly digest your content. Without it, your content risks falling into the black hole of the internet.

Playing by the new rules

Today, getting clicks isn’t about rankings; it’s about gaining the trust of our AI overlords—or in other words, creating content that positions you as an authoritative source worthy of being summarized by Gen AI.

To appear in AI overviews, your content needs to:

  1. Address specific search queries 
  2. Include semantically related words
  3. Use concise, informative statements 
  4. Structure for scannability
  5. Offer original insights and data
  6. Build authority through citations and backlinking
  7. Use schema markup

Amid this new landscape, adaptation is an urgent matter for enterprise marketing teams. 

Since 2010, MarketSmiths has created high-visibility content for thousands of brands, playing by a constantly changing rulebook as the marketing world shifted from the blogosphere to social media to AI-dominated channels. Whatever the game, we create copy and other media that helps enterprises subvert the rules and cream the competition. 

Erin Kahn

Erin Kahn

Erin Kahn is a writer and printmaker based outside of Boston. In her free time, she enjoys throwing literary parties and exploring cemeteries.

Contact MarketSmiths

Reach out to learn more and get captivating copywriting.

More from MarketSmiths

fall movies copywriting

Cats, Mr. Rogers, and Star Wars: What Fall’s New Movies Can Tell You About Your Copy

https://www.pexels.com/photo/plants-macro-growth-soil-113335/

On Visions, Goals, and Achieving Growth

Your SEO strategy should reflect consumer behavior.

SEO is Evolving—Here’s How to Evolve With It

copywriting for grownups

Are You Talking Like a Grown-Up? Crafting Copy to Address Audiences 50 Years and Older

Corporate Storytelling

SPARK™ Sessions

Research / Analysis

Brand Story & Tone

Messaging / Pillars

Campaign Calendar

Digital Ecology

Corporate Journalism

Copywriting

Creative Services

Content Design Services

Video Script & Production

Website Design & Dev

Content Strategy

Content Gap Analysis

Semantic SEO & GEO

Content Governance

Closed Loop Analytics

Content Workflow

Design by WorstOfAllDesign. Digital Strategy by MadPipe. Photography by Chellise Michael.